ベルベットラブ アイライナーペンシル (メタリックアイス)

The pigmentation is unreal for a pencil — one swipe and the metallic ice shade shows up bold with zero tugging on my lid. The gel formula glides on so creamy that I could sketch a sharp wing without any wobbly lines. Honestly, it’s everything I wanted from a luxury liner.

It glides on so smoothly that I didn't even need to press hard for the metallic shimmer to show up, and the gel texture stays put through my whole workday. Only reason it's not five stars is the tip needs a few seconds to warm up before the color really pops.