Velvet Love Eyeliner Pencil (Metallic Bronze)

I was skeptical a pencil could give this much drama, but one stroke along my lash line delivered that metallic bronze payoff exactly as promised. It’s creamy enough to smudge into a smoky eye yet holds a sharp point for a precise wing, and it lasted through a full workday without fading.

That first swipe glides on so smooth it feels like gel, not a pencil. The bronze has that rich metallic pop that makes my eyes look awake even after a 6am flight, and it stays put through a full workday without smudging.

The metallic bronze shade is gorgeous and the gel formula glides on so smoothly that I got a perfect wing on my first try. One stroke really is all it takes for that dramatic definition, and it stays creamy without tugging at my lids.